Tottenham ask about Gustavo Varela and Monza say £29m, but a January loan for Freiburg’s 6ft 4in striker makes more sense

Tottenham have asked Monza about Gustavo Varela and been told the price is £29m, but the cheaper and smarter January route to goals may be a loan for Freiburg’s Igor Matanovic.
Both names are on the list as Tottenham look for a striker before the window opens. Spurs have scored 10 goals in 10 Premier League games, Dominic Solanke and Omar Marmoush have only three between them, and no player in the squad has more than two.
That is the backdrop as Roberto De Zerbi’s side return to action against Ipswich Town at home on Saturday. The question is not whether Spurs need goals. It is what kind of deal they should do in the middle of the season.
What would £29m buy Tottenham?
Varela is the hottest young striker in Italy right now. The 21-year-old Portuguese forward has nine goals in ten Serie A games for Monza, which has put him at the top of the scoring chart and brought Arsenal, Juventus and Barcelona to the door as well.
Spurs have now requested information on him, and Monza have set an asking price of £29m. That is a huge mark-up on a player who only arrived from Benfica in the summer and whose contract runs to 2030, so the Italian club hold all the cards.
He is quick, has a good first touch and has finished brilliantly this season. The catch is the sample size. Last season, on loan at Gil Vicente, he scored six goals in 32 games, and before that he played mostly for Benfica’s B team. Ten games in Serie A is a short run to hang £29m on.
Can Varela handle the Premier League?
His physical game is the worry. He is not the strongest striker, and De Zerbi will want a number nine who can hold the ball against two centre-backs when Spurs go long to beat a press. Varela may grow into that, but January is not the time to find out.
Why a Matanovic loan looks the better fit
The other option is very different. Igor Matanovic, the 6ft 4in Croatia international at Freiburg, is a name Tottenham like, and a short-term loan has been floated as a possible route if they decide to bring a striker in this winter.
The numbers are steadier than Varela’s. Matanovic has four goals in nine Bundesliga games this season and eight in 16 in all competitions, after 11 league goals in 31 appearances last season. Before that, he scored 14 times in 32 games on loan at Karlsruher SC in the second tier.
He is also the bigger, more aerial striker of the two, and he would give Spurs something neither Solanke nor Marmoush offers: a target in the box for the wide players to aim at.
Will Freiburg actually let him go?
This is the hard part. Matanovic is 23, a key player for Freiburg and under contract until 2029. He is valued at around £50m, and Pochettino’s Manchester United are also said to be keen. Clubs rarely loan out a starting striker in January unless there is an obligation to buy attached, so any deal would need careful structuring.
Richarlison could help pay for it
There is one way Tottenham can make room. Richarlison, frozen out of the senior squad after asking to leave in the summer, has six months left on his contract, and Spurs have lowered their price to around £10m to £15m. Trabzonspor have contacted the club and spoken to his camp, though the Brazilian would rather stay in the Premier League.
That valuation will only fall as January goes on, because any buyer knows he can leave for free in the summer. Spurs would be wise to take a fair offer early rather than wait for deadline day, especially after letting Will Lankshear go in the summer, a striker who has since been scoring freely in the Championship.
Varela or Matanovic: which striker should Tottenham go for?
For us, it is Matanovic on loan, if Freiburg will allow it. A short deal fixes the goal problem now without committing £29m to ten good games, and it keeps the summer open for a proper long-term number nine. We made a similar point when we looked at what De Zerbi needs in January, and nothing over the break has changed it.
Varela is worth watching. If he is still scoring at this rate in the spring, and his physical game has grown, Spurs can come back for him then. Paying full price in mid-season for a striker with one good autumn behind him is how clubs end up with expensive regrets.