Worst defence in the league, a fading England hopeful and no striker scoring: what Thomas Frank inherits at Crystal Palace

By November 17, 2026
Steve Parish Crystal Palace
Advertisement

Thomas Frank is officially the new Crystal Palace head coach, and the job he has taken is about as hard as it gets: bottom of the Premier League, the worst defence in the division and only a few training sessions before a trip to Coventry City on Saturday.

Palace confirmed the appointment on Monday, days after Pierre Sage was sacked after less than five months in charge. Frank has signed a contract until June 2029 and is back in management for the first time since Tottenham dismissed him in February.

“It’s an honour to sit here and be in charge of this fantastic football club,” Frank told the club’s website. Chairman Steve Parish called him “the perfect fit for our club” and pointed to his record of “creating winning teams and improving players”.

Improving players is exactly what Crystal Palace need. Here is what he has inherited, and where we think he has to start.

How bad is it at Crystal Palace?

Bad enough. Palace have won two, drawn one and lost seven of their ten league games, and they go into the international break on four straight defeats. They have scored ten and let in 24.

PosClubPlayedPointsGoal difference
17thCoventry City109-9
18thManchester United108-5
19thSunderland108-9
20thCrystal Palace107-14

The good news is that it is tight. Coventry are only two points ahead in 17th, so a win at the Coventry Building Society Arena would lift Palace out of the bottom three and up to 16th. We set out how that first fixture fell for him in our report on Frank closing in on the job.

Problem one: a defence that leaks goals

Twenty-four goals conceded in ten games is the worst record in the league, and eight of them have come from set pieces, four during this losing run. That was an issue before Sage arrived, too, so this is not just one coach’s mess.

The squad is part of the story. Palace never properly replaced Marc Guehi and Maxence Lacroix, and the summer signings at the back, Takehiro Tomiyasu, Axel Disasi on loan from Chelsea and 18-year-old Honest Ahanor, have not given them the solidity they needed.

Back three or back four?

Frank’s Brentford switched between a 3-5-2 and a 4-3-3, and we would expect him to start with the three. The players already know it, and with so little time before Coventry, keeping the shape familiar while he fixes the details makes more sense than tearing it up.

The bigger decision is personnel. Disasi has a real chance to become a leader here, but Frank has to work out quickly whether he is the right partner for the others or whether January has to bring another centre-back.

Set pieces at both ends

This is where Frank could make the quickest difference. His Brentford sides were among the best in the league for expected goals from set pieces, and that kind of detail works in your own box as well as the opponent’s. For a team conceding from corners and free-kicks as often as Palace, a week on the training ground could be worth points straight away.

Problem two: getting Adam Wharton back

Not long ago Adam Wharton was being linked with Chelsea, Manchester City and Liverpool. Now the 22-year-old missed out on England’s World Cup squad, and the noise around him has gone quiet.

His average performance rating has dropped from fourth-best among Palace players last season to seventh this term, with fewer accurate long balls and key passes per 90. Part of the reason looks tactical: under Sage he has been asked to track runners and screen the defence, which is not his game.

In our view, Frank’s job is simple to say and hard to do. Give Wharton a partner who does the running, and let him get on the ball and dictate. A Wharton playing like the old Wharton would help the defence and the attack in one go.

Problem three: who scores the goals?

Jean-Philippe Mateta wanted to leave in the summer, is heading into the final months of his contract and has been hit by injury. He has not scored in the league this season and has more red cards than goals.

Jorgen Strand Larsen has one goal in eight league games, and his record of 19 in 79 top-flight appearances does not scream long-term answer. He also left Norway’s camp with an ankle problem this month, although he was expected to be fine for Coventry.

That points to January. Richarlison, who played under Frank at Tottenham and looks available, is one name that fits. The catch is money: Palace brought in 11 players in the summer, and Parish may not want to fund another big recruitment drive.

Is Thomas Frank the right man for Crystal Palace?

His record is mixed. At Tottenham he won 13 of his 38 games and left them 16th, five points above the drop. At Brentford he spent seven years building something, won promotion in 2020-21 and then finished 13th, ninth, 16th and tenth in the Premier League. Across 178 Premier League games as a manager, he has won 61, drawn 46 and lost 71.

We think Palace is a better fit for him than Spurs ever was. This is a club that needs organisation, set-piece detail and players who get better, not a manager handling huge expectations. Those are the things Frank did best at Brentford.

But the timing is brutal. Coventry away, with the worst defence in the league and no reliable striker, is a must-win game before he has had a proper week with the squad. If he can get the back line organised and Wharton back on the ball, the rest can wait for January. If he cannot, Palace’s 13-year stay in the top flight is in real danger.

Advertisement
Advertisement