Forest and Everton go head to head for Gremio’s £12.5m centre-back, with the Brazilian club staring at relegation

Nottingham Forest and Everton are set to go head to head for Gremio centre-back Gustavo Martins, a 24-year-old Brazilian whose club are hovering above the relegation zone and have already put a price on him of up to €15m (£12.5m).
According to Fussball Europa, Martins has emerged as a target for both Premier League clubs. Gremio are reported to want between €12m (£10m) and €15m (£12.5m) for a defender whose contract runs until December 2027.
Both clubs go into the international break with solid defensive records. Nottingham Forest have conceded 13 goals in 10 games, and Everton have let in only ten, the joint-fourth best record in the division. Yet the two sides sit far apart in the table, with David Moyes’ team sixth and Oliver Glasner’s 16th.
Who is Gustavo Martins?
Martins is mainly a centre-back, but he has also played at right-back, and that versatility is part of the appeal. He has been a regular for Gremio this season, starting 21 of his 24 appearances, and he has scored 13 goals in 129 games for the club in total, a good return for a defender.
The timing could suit a buyer. Gremio are 18th in the Brasileiro, and if they go down to the second tier they are likely to be flooded with offers for him. With just over a year left on his deal, the asking price could come under pressure either way.
Why would Forest want Gustavo Martins?
There is an obvious link. Forest have a strong Brazilian group at the City Ground, which could make a move there an easy one for Martins to settle into. Glasner’s side also showed what they can do in their 3-1 win over Manchester City, a result that lifted them out of the bottom three before the break.
The problem is space. Forest already have four senior centre-backs, Murillo, Nikola Milenkovic, Ousmane Diomande and Jair Cunha, all on long-term contracts. Martins would not be the first January name linked with that position either: we covered Forest’s interest in Birmingham’s Phil Neumann last week, and the same question applied then. Where does he play?
Forest would need a sale first
For Martins to make sense at Forest, someone would probably have to leave. Otherwise he would be swapping a starting place in Brazil for a fight to get into the matchday squad, which is a hard sell for a player who has started almost every game this season.
Is Everton the better move for Martins?
On paper, yes. Two of Everton‘s top three central defenders, James Tarkowski and Michael Keane, are 33, and Moyes is generally short of depth across the squad. Jarrad Branthwaite has also had to be managed carefully this season.
That gives Martins a clearer route into the side at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, and a chance to learn from two experienced centre-backs while pushing them for a place. Everton have also been looking at South America for defensive cover, with interest in Atlético Mineiro’s 18-year-old Vitão reported last week.
Does the price work for both clubs?
At €12m to €15m, he is not a cheap punt, but for a 24-year-old starter who can cover two positions, it is a reasonable figure by Premier League standards. Forest have shown in recent windows that they like to buy younger players they can sell on later, and Martins fits that age profile. For Everton, the value lies in planning for the moment Tarkowski and Keane can no longer play every week.
Verdict: Forest have the link, Everton have the pathway
If Martins is choosing on comfort, Forest’s Brazilian contingent is a strong pull. If he is choosing on minutes, Everton is the obvious answer.
Our view: Forest should only move if a centre-back leaves, because a fifth senior option would leave someone frustrated. Everton need this type of player more than Forest do, and with Moyes’ side sixth and defending as well as anyone, adding a younger centre-back to that back line now would be a smart piece of planning. If Gremio go down, expect the competition for him to get a lot busier than two Premier League clubs.